Logo Jst No Paddings MiniLogo Jst No Paddings MiniLogo Jst No Paddings MiniLogo Jst No Paddings Mini
  • HOME
  • Services
  • E-learning
  • Blog
  • About me
  • Contact
✕
English
  • Czech

GIGA tools and tempering

Categories
  • Nadca 207
  • TAV Furnaces
Tags

A lot has already been explained about hardening furnaces. But what about tempering? To give you an idea, there are a few certainties in our forecasts.

  • There will always be only one part in the furnace, weighing several tons
  • There will always be at least 3 temperings, maybe even more
  • Even though Nadca-207 says that tempering in air is possible, I have been trying to completely rule out this idea for a long time. A protective atmosphere must always be applied. Only if we have allowances larger than 0.5 mm on the entire part, which we machine from all sides of the shaped part after hardening and tempering, i.e. from non-functional surfaces, can we use air. The basis is AMS 2759 and their definition of surface types Type 1 to 4, and the classification of atmospheres into A, B and C. If you don’t believe it, it will be too late when you find out. I already have the experience. In addition, it is necessary to consider that we will carry out annealing after EDM, after welding, after testing, where the entire working cavity or part of it is already free of machining allowances
  • The temperature of the part must be controlled by a thermocouple in the Tc core, as is common for this type of processing according to Nadca-207. Otherwise, we cannot ensure repeatable hardness values
  • The furnace class according to Nadca-207 is prescribed at +/-14°C. However, since there is also a reference to CQI-9, in Process Table A, point A2.4, +/-10°C is specified here. Since neither of these standards is prepared for GIGA dies, it must be said that +/- 5°C is my recommendation. And why +/-5°C? There is something like the Hollomon-Jaffe parameter, which quantifies the influence of tempering temperature and time according to the formula: P = T*(C+log10 t). If the tempering temperature is 570 °C and the time is 2 hours, then P565​=15*(20+log10​2) and the time tekv = 1.52 h. This number tells us that tempering for 2 h at 565 °C has approximately the same tempering effect as 1.52 h at 570 °C. The hottest spot will be 570+5°C with tekv = 2.64 h. The difference is almost double, at +/-10°C it is three times and at +/14°C it is more than four times.

  • If we use multiple batch thermocouples, and I see this as almost a necessity, the 2-hour tempering time will start when the coldest thermocouple reaches the lower limit of the temperature field tolerance, Tload,min≥TSP​−ΔTuniformity​. This also corresponds to aviation standards such as AMS 2774, AMS 2759/D, AMS 2801, etc. For furnace class 5 it will be -14°C, for furnace class 4 -10°C and for furnace class 2 -5°C.
  • When cooling after tempering, it is necessary to take into account that during slow cooling, prolonged stay of the part at temperatures of 550 to 350°C can cause internal structural changes leading to a decrease in toughness. This is mainly the precipitation of Cr, Mo, V carbides, along with their coarsening and coalescence. At the same time, high Si and P contents can cause temper embrittlement. Steels with higher Si content (H11) will be more susceptible to this embrittlement than modern steels with lower Si content (Daido-GIGA, MT1, Dievar) [1]. The cooling rate after tempering is not defined anywhere, but it should be as high as possible, both for the reasons mentioned above and also for the economy of cooling parts weighing several tons
  • The end tempering cooling temperature must always be Ts= 50 C.
  • As with quenching, a square chamber will be more efficient than a round chamber
  • If we temper in air, we must work only with an atmospheric pressure of 1 bar abs.
  • If we temper in a retort furnace, we usually have an overpressure of only a few mbar, and in addition, I have to heat and cool a retort weighing hundreds of kg with each cycle
  • If we temper in a vacuum furnace, we usually have the option of up to 1.5 bar abs. This overpressure is usually tied to the design of the furnace door. However, an overpressure of 0.5 bar will not be sufficient for effective cooling of such massive parts after tempering
  • If we deal with the design and closure of the door, we can go to higher pressures, e.g. 3 bar abs. Both during convection heating and cooling. And what is the difference? At a pressure of 1 bar abs. we will have a heat transfer of approximately 30 W/m2K, at 3 bar then twice as much, 60 W/m2K.  For one tempering cycle for the reference block, we will save up to 15 hours of time. With triple tempering, it is 45 hours, almost 2 days.

  • During rapid convection heating, it is necessary to control the difference Ts−Tc, because it creates transient thermal stresses. The infographic shows that during heating, even at 1 bar abs. we can exceed the recommended difference dT = Ts-Tc ≤110 C according to Nadca 207. So even if the part did not crack during hardening, it can happen during tempering. And not only because of dT, but also because of the simultaneous transformation of austenite to martensite. So for heating, I would be very careful with increasing the pressure, for cooling it makes sense both economically and metallurgically.

  • But can we go even higher with the overpressure during tempering? The following figure shows the case where we increase the pressure to 5 bar abs. Surprisingly, we will get into a situation where the efficiency of this step will have a lower impact. If we increase the pressure during tempering from 1 to 3 bar abs., the cooling efficiency will increase by 45%, while if we increase it from 3 bar to 5 bar abs. then only by 20-30%. However, the demands on the pressure vessel, the performance of the cooling fan, and a larger heat exchanger will increase. 3 bar abs. therefore seems to be a good compromise.

What to say in conclusion? In single-chamber vacuum furnaces, solutions designed for tool hardening or for aerospace applications prevail. It is surprising when the tempering operation is as important as hardening.

Many will argue that I can temper in this way in a hardening furnace. In terms of overpressure during cooling, I have much greater options. Yes, I do. But the hardening furnace is designed for hardening, i.e. high temperatures, and we are operating in the range of low temperatures to which the hardening furnace is not fully adapted. The second objection is economics. As can be seen from the analysis, the tempering cycle times are almost 24 hours or more, and I cannot harden during this period. And since I need to temper at least 3 times, the purpose of the hardening furnace, the most expensive link in the entire chain, will not be used. The processing prices will be disproportionately high, as the hourly costs of a quenching furnace will be significantly higher than for a tempering furnace, usually up to 3 times.

Do you agree with what I have said? You don’t have to, but it is gratifying that TAV Vacuum Furnaces is already able to supply such a furnace.

 

[1] Mesquita, Rafael Agnelli; Barbosa, Celso Antonio; Kestenbach, Hans-Jürgen; Gonçalves, Cristiane Sales. EFEITO DO Si E P NA TENACIDADE DO AÇO H11, UTILIZADO EM FERRAMENTAS DE TRABALHO A QUENTE, p. 2768-2777. In: 61º Congresso Anual da ABM, Rio de Janeiro, 2006, ISSN: 2594-5327, DOI 10.5151/2594-5327-2005-14508-0311

=======================================================================================================
Are you solving a similar problem? I will help you with the analysis…
✔ 40+ years of experience in the field
✔ 30+ years of experience… HT-PROGRES, Bodycote, Galvamet
✔ cooperation… VŠB, Czechimplant, ECM Technologies, TAV Vacuum Furnaces, GHC Invest
✔ 12+ years of expert activity
Want to ask for a solution or want a non-binding consultation? Click on this link, I will usually respond within 24 hours. Contact email
========================================================================================================
Jiří Stanislav, Ing. CSc.
Consultant and forensic expert
========================================================================================================

31/8/2026

Related posts

Magnets? Is it an opportunity?


Read more

Round or square hot zone?


Read more

So here it is ….


Read more

Jiří Stanislav, Ing., CSc.

Consultant for heat treatment of metals

Forensic expert in metallurgy and heat treatment of metals

IČ: 02232413

Elišky Krásnohorské 965
Liberec 14, 46001 Česká Republika

[email protected]

+420 603 235 924

Information

  • General terms and conditions of sale of courses

Cookie settings

Contact

[email protected]

+420 603 235 924

© 2021 tvorbu webu realizoval SEMTIX.cz
    0

    €0,00

    English
    • Czech
    • English

      Cookies on this website

      We use necessary cookies to make the website work (cart, language). With your consent we also use analytics cookies (Google Analytics, Microsoft Clarity) to improve the website and marketing cookies (Google Ads) to measure and target advertising. You can change your choice at any time via “Cookie settings” in the footer. Cookie policy (Czech)